I feel that if Charlotte Temple were written today, the story would take a completely different turn. I believe that with all the technology that teens have at their finger tips Charlotte would have been able to more easily take herself out of the situation that she was in. I feel that she would be better connected with her over protective parents and that her meeting Montraville would have been noted online. With that being said, I also believe that the message of the story would be lost if it were written today. When it was written, people were used to not having the same means to contact each other. Families and friends could go for days, months, and sometimes even years without speaking together or knowing what was going on in each other's lives, while today, our friends and family have a play by play of what we are doing with the help of facebook status updates and text messaging.
I feel that in a modern Charlotte Temple, there would have been facebook/twitter/myspace updates of her meetings with Montraville as well as text messages. Also, with the help of cell phone gps systems, she would have been able to be tracked down more easily. Though there are many things that would change in a modern Charlotte Temple, the greatest change would be that of the theme. If all the technological advancements today were implemented, the end of the story would change completely and the moral would be lost.
Learning in the Age of the Trigger Warning
-
Why are people scared to learn? Why has knowledge become intimidating? Over
the past few months, these questions have carved out a niche in the back of
my ...
11 years ago
I totally agree that the story as written could never take place today. As for kids keeping secrets from their parents, even with all the online communications kids are excellent at hiding what they want to hide. Also parents usually believe the best in their children, and don't want to see the ugly truth that may lie beneath the shiny exterior. Kids today dont care if they get pregnant, there are solutions to those types of problems, and its not uncommon to see girls at a high school pregnant.
ReplyDeleteI liked your post about technology playing a part in the modern version of Charlotte Temple. Things have been changing for many years and the use of just a telephone would have changed the entire story. Somehow, the story would have lost a lot of its charm if the setting were modern day. I think all the elements that led to Charlotte's isolation -- the long boat trip overseas, the inability to communicate other than by mail, and her stay in the country helped to cement the notion that she was all alone. It was a very different time and that her options were very limited.
ReplyDelete